Skip to main content

If you care, you question.

Morpheus asked Neo:

Do you think that's air you're breathing now?

This question changed the way Neo thought about everything. The question triggered a process. A shock, a surge of anger seeing his long standing beliefs coming to a breaking point before his own eyes, followed by a strong denial (that it can't be actually happening!!), followed by coming to terms with the fact that many of the strong beliefs were in fact statements easily falsifiable in another world, followed by greater understanding of self and the world around.

The moments of dismay caused due to such questions can be as few as one wants them to be. All it takes is assuming some large set of axioms as truths of our lives and building upon them. The larger your set of assumptions (foundations!!) stronger the strength of your beliefs and more is smoothness in your life. In the pursuit of simple, easy and often smooth life one admits this route. Beaware, thats a route always waiting for you around every corner. And laziness of human mind, the the need for stability and sometimes inertia force us to such a route.

The other route, however, one needs to search for. I will call that other route a golden route. Precious!!

No one is Clean "Dudh se dhula": I feel we all always try to simplify things for ourselves. We all make covenient assumptions in some or the other aspects, if not all. Some take for granted the love from their parents so that the obligation of giving back in that relationship doesn't weigh upon them. Some assume love of their spouce as something unquestionable. We all come with our own set of unquestionable areas. We are all stained and we are all in there.

Where are the golden path walkers then? Whats the gradation among us all who have diverged onto that simple path? Is there anybody better than the other?


Well, some never take the golden road. And some pass that route along some walks of life. And gradation: I think gradation depends on the number of times one crosses or reaches the golden road or in other words the number of different aspects of life one questions. The ideal would be to absolutely question everything. Right from love we feel for any living and non living being. Any and every irrational thoughts that cross mind at random times. The rules and ethics we have been told to live by. But then it may not really be possible. For example, a person who wants to ask important questions in science and spends his life doing so may not manage to give mental space to questions related to political issues around him. I am ofcourse not saying its correct. I am just sayings thats how it may turn out to be. To be able to focus all your resources (mental more than anything else. But also resources such as money, time or more practical one's) on too many issues may not just be feasible. But the ideal human being, whose life I assure will end up in complete chaos, is the one who dares to question everything. The other end of spetrum obviously is where one never questions anything. Like a child you just assume some axioms as told by parents, as told by some leaders or if nothing else, as told by society.

As an aside, I'll like to mention something about this evil called Society. Society, who is it? I know anybody like that. A really nice book I read said the following about the concept "society": ----when someone threatens you of society, in fact, that person who is treatening is himself the society. Its actually that person who is getting annoyed and is trying to hide behind an unknown face of the society to force you to do things---- I believe, society exists as much as the ghosts do. They exist if you want them to. Not otherwise.

Anyways, going back to questioning everything. In the gradation, let me place people who question everything they care about as somwhere in between these two ends of the spectrum.

If you think working for some NGO is the most important thing in your life. Then you should continuosly question this aspect of your life. May be after 5 years you may not care about it as much as you did when you started (May be the NGO has changed its form so much so that it hardly matches your covictions). But by then it has become part of your system and you don't even realise you have stopped caring for it. These are the ungaurded moments when one gets onto that simple path. (Just go on, one tells one self. You are in a circle where people know you, respect you, why leave? A convenience strategy) Ofcourse, it all starts with great questioning. But soon gets into a state of inertia. Same applies to all our interactions. We start them with good faith and nothing else. But do we question them enough? Our brain is not a static system sitting around without change. But one just gets tired of keeping track of how much it has changed. Thats a pity.

I now come to the main point of why I started saying all this.

I believe, the only way to care about some aspect of life is by subjecting it to a rigorous questioning every now and then. I mean, what would it mean to be interested in something if you don't even invest enough mental faculties into considering and reconsidering the foundations of your interests. There is no taking for granted if you really care about something/someone. In fact once you take for granted, rest assured, the thing of interest becomes totally invisible to you. One gets side tracked from where it started into this convenient path and probably in a vicious loop where your brain is trained to behave in a certain way that creates environment conducive for a kind of harmony. But the essence of the very source of that path is lost.
In nutshell, to justify your likings/interests into anything at all you must question every thing possible about it.

Comments

Anonymous said…
I am sorry but i completely disagree with your logic. If the question wheter I am really interested or not comes in the mind regularly, then that itself is a sign that you really are not interested in it. I mean if you like something or are passionate about it then that question would not even come up in your mind. the very fact that one is even questioning it suggests that, there is some kind of doubt in your mind somewhere about your passion, and that is the sign, that your passion is going down. In the beginning, we are very excited about some thing and we are passionate about it. There is a great thrill in dreaming about what we want to do and how its going to be a exciting life and all. Then when we are deep in the nitty-gritty of the very activity we were passionate about, we dont feel as thrilled about it as we used to, this is true for anything and everything. This does not mean that the passion has reduced...it has just matured, and taken a new form. Once in a while it makes sense to go back and think about what is it that got you so excited about it, but if you have to do that every now and then, then that is the first sign, that one has lost that passion.
Anonymous said…
Wow, that was heavy!
Nutan said…
To the first anonymous: Why is this an assumption that what you are passionate about today you will be tomorrow also? If I love talking to a person today, why would I even tomorrow?.... is it really necessary?....thats why questioning is a must. Say today you love your work.... and suddenly tomorrow you don't! (and I am not saying that you don't love it as much because it has become more complicated or something like that...) You simply stop liking it.... For no reason or no fault of yours.... but because we are so used to thinking that once we have a passion, or once we like something we have to continue liking it (it also reflects in your tone, I am afraid)...we just continue.... it happens to marriages, it happens to friendships, it happens to your work, it happens all over...people feel stuck..and thats mainly because they don't like to admit to themselves that they hate (that may be a strong word....may be they don't like something as much) what they loved before... so i feel questioning is a must.....
Nice to have received a comment from you... next time also write your name or some identity so that i don't have to call you anonymous 1

anonymous 2:... i am not sure why i accepted this comment.... it hardly says anything!! anyway, thanks for stopping by....
Anonymous said…
hi, this is the first anon. Firstly i am not saying that interests dont fluctuate, ofcourse they do. I said that, when ur interests are strong, then there is no need to question urself....questions arise precisely when ones interests or passions go down, its then that doubts arise.

"You simply stop liking it.... For no reason or no fault of yours...."

I am sorry, i dont agree with that at all. nothing happens without a reason, atleast not with me.

Newton's first law of motion i think is valid in life too....

"In the absence of any external force..things remain the same".

Yes interests can change, i may like my work today, i may not tomorrow...but there is usually a reason for it....i could be under stress for other reasons. It slowly could have dawned to me, that i am not good at what i am doing.....that can be a big depressing factor. There are innumerable reasons .....
Anonymous said…
"nothing happens without a reason, atleast not with me."....

Thats for you.... but it has happened to me a few times that with same parameters, i have totally stopped liking something that i did before..... now of course you might say how do you know there was no "inherent underlying reason"..etc etc.... so thats a digression i won't like to take..it has no end....

i find it strange that you quote Newton's laws.. :)... precisely to contradict what the post is saying...which is essentially this law you state.... because for me, the simple path is where on ends up and stays in intertia and to go back to the golden path you need extermal force!!! so the law you state is like a summary, but u seem to understand it wrongly....

Popular posts from this blog

Slumdog Millionaire, what's the fuss all about?

I saw the movie a few days ago. I really don't understand: why so much fuss? If an Indian director makes a fully filmy hindi movie, no one gives a damn about it. But some non-indian comes and makes this movie and people are going all ga ga about it. A.R. Rehman has given music better than "jai ho". Anil Kapur has done roles better than this. This movie has set new records in making a big deal out of a not-so-amazing movie. I say this because, even a huge fuss has been made about why there is so much fuss about this movie. That is like the second order fuss about the movie! And here, I am making the third order fuss with a huge lot accompanying me in doing so. To start the tirade-- The main guy is such a put off! He has a unique expression on his face, indicating he really has no clue what people are talking about. You are supposed to be poor, not dumb for god's sake! Even some of the witty lines are lost due to his dialog delivery. For example, when one police man say...

The "What next...?" demon

What next?.... When I was a kid, I always thought that there is a certain age till when this question will bother me and after that, like for my parents, things will be in order. Life will fall into a routine and I will never again be confronted with this demon called "what next?". But turns out, for our generation, there is no point of rest. The demon is a part of our life like stability was for the generation before us. This realisation is also stale by now. In fact, it has been more than a few years since I even resigned to this way of life. The time period between such a realisation and resignation was hard, I must confess. But not anymore! The confrontations with this demon are a reassurance of life itself! (feels embarrassed after having said such things....) My childish philosophies may be sounding hilarious to you (reader). (Thank me for the entertainment! You are welcome!) What I wish to announce is: for a while, I do have an answer to one such "what next...?...

Valentine's special

its a love story of two strange people who never knew they could fall for each other when they first met they only ended up fighting but slowy it became clear to them that they sure shared something a small problem happened when pride overtook him he thought she was less smarter than him she would solve a puzzle and he would solve it again he would tell her that she was simply an idea away from him... he said that he always gets this idea and then he does all that she can and probably much more... one day she decided his behaviour had to be checked she thought for a while and then she said... fine, then you sure can do everything but if you are strictly more smart you have to do the following think of some puzzle that you can easily do and then give it to me to solve and lets see if i can't do.... all the king's men and all the king's horses could not come up with a puzzle like this the duo got closer and the world around more curious today as it stands the puzzle is still ...